1. Dimensions and design
Comfort in use and presentable appearanceFor comparison, we chose capacious frying pans 26–28 cm. All models are available in several versions of different diameters at once. This is very convenient when you like the pan, but its size does not suit you. It is also important to pay attention to the diameter and thickness of the bottom, the height of the walls and the weight of the vessel. Tefal and Rondell have too thin material, which makes them not suitable for cooking some dishes. The rest of the products have the same thickness - the bottom is 6 mm and the walls are 4–4.5 mm.
Kukmara looks solid and reliable, cooking on it is a pleasure. Thanks to the optimal diameter, the impressive thickness of the bottom and walls, the pan turned out to be durable, while it is not the heaviest in the rating. It is problematic to choose a suitable lid; otherwise, consumers have no complaints about the dimensions and design of kitchen utensils. Branded packaging is pleasantly pleasing, but a lot depends on the chosen supplier and the work of postal services in case of ordering via the Internet.
For the manufacture of the Dream pan, the manufacturer used cast thick-walled aluminum. Its thermal storage properties allow food to cook evenly. She languishes inside the vessel, nothing burns. A strong base with a maximum diameter not only contributes to rapid heating, but also minimizes the risk of deformation. Unfortunately, due to the increased thickness of the bottom, the weight of the product also increased.
Tefal received good marks for design and ease of care. Working with utensils is convenient and pleasant due to its low weight and ergonomic shape. But even this vessel was not the lightest in the ranking, because Rondell weighs a little less than a kilogram. The almost weightless frying pan is made of induction-safe extruded aluminum. On the outside of the product there is a special heat-resistant coating that facilitates care and washing.
The Neva combines high sides and a fairly large usable bottom area. Due to this, it is suitable for frying any meat, fish, vegetables, side dishes with a large number of ingredients. In addition, it is this vessel that has the highest walls. Nothing will burn or spill out while cooking. The bottom is ribbed, due to which the material does not slip on smooth burners. All pans are supplied without a lid, and this is the main disadvantage. Although you can buy it separately, it still requires additional investment and time.
Name | Top diameter | bottom diameter | bottom thickness | Wall height | Wall thickness | The weight | User rating for design |
Kukmara Granite Ultra | 26 cm | 19 cm | 0.6 cm | 6.5 cm | 0.45 cm | 1.25 kg | 4.9 |
Dream Granite | 28 cm | 22.5 cm | 0.6 cm | 6.5 cm | 0.4 cm | 1.62 kg | 4.8 |
Tefal Cook Right | 28 cm | 22 cm | 0.25 cm | 5 cm | 0.25 cm | 1.75 kg | 4.9 |
Rondell Massimo | 28 cm | 19.5 cm | 0.25 cm | 5.3 cm | 0.25 cm | 0.82 kg | 4.8 |
NEVA METAL WARE Special 90 | 26 cm | 18 cm | 0.6 cm | 6.8 cm | 0.4 cm | 1.26 kg | 4.8 |
Tefal Cook Right
The most comfortable
2. Coating
The most important criterion for a non-stick panThere are different types of non-stick coatings: diamond, granite, ceramic, marble, Teflon, titanium and Excalibur. All of them have certain pros and cons. The rating includes models coated with granite, titanium and Teflon. Rondell's non-stick surface consists of only two layers, while other manufacturers make multi-layer designs for better protection and effective control of sticking.
Granite coating of Kukmara is made according to German technology. It is called innovative and incredibly durable. The so-called Ultra Granite layer is reinforced with new generation minerals, in terms of hardness they can compete with diamonds. Due to this, the service life is increased by 6 times in comparison with the average utensils. It is also important that a special technology from the German company Weilburger Coatigs Gmbh is used here. Its main advantage is the ability to stir the ingredients with metal kitchen utensils.
The latest formula of heavy-duty non-stick coating is a feature of the product from Mechta. It will be possible to cook with it almost without oil, while the food will turn out delicious, and the juice will not leak out. The product is of high quality and safe, the coating belongs to the Greblon brand. The five-layer coating "TitanPK" of the second generation on a water basis provides the Neva frying pan with a long service life, increased strength and wear resistance. The manufacturer promises up to 8000 cycles of work. Buyers in the reviews confirm that even after 3 years of operation there are no bubbles or scratches.
Tefal has a classic Teflon coating.This is one of the first non-stick pans on the market. The main advantage can be called safety and the possibility of frying completely without oil. The most significant disadvantage is that over time, the coating gradually loses its properties, and there is still a risk of deformation during severe overheating.
Dream Granite
The most popular
3. Ease of use
User ratings and checking utensils in operationThe easiest way to draw conclusions about the quality and convenience of dishes is to study the reviews on Yandex.Market and other sites. Real customer opinions with ratings for each criterion will help you quickly decide. Users consider Kukmara and Tefal non-stick pans to be the easiest to care for. They are easy to wash and wipe off even dried-on pieces of food, the products will last a long time. Other models received much lower scores. Kukmara is also convenient because it can be put in the dishwasher. But for an induction cooker, the product is completely unsuitable, like other options.
Tefal was remembered by customers many years ago thanks to an unusual circle in the middle of the bottom, which turns bright red when heated. This is really convenient, because you can immediately understand that the pot has reached the required temperature for frying. Oddly enough, it is the indicator that is often complained about in reviews. For many buyers, it almost does not change color.
Another interesting criterion is a convenient holder. It is important to clarify here that non-stick pans with a removable or fixed handle are on sale.The first option is suitable for baking in the oven. An added benefit is the savings in storage space. And these models are much easier and more convenient to wash.
Even removable holders differ from each other in the attachment mechanism. It can be push-button, in the form of a lever or a clamp. It is also worth paying attention to the material from which the handle is made. It should not overheat during cooking, otherwise it will be problematic to work with kitchen utensils without potholders. As a rule, holders are made of Bakelite.
A removable handle is provided for the Neva and Mechta models. Therefore, each of them can be put in the oven. Both pans do a good job with their main task, but over time, carbon deposits inevitably form. You have to wash the dishes with a hard sponge, which leads to scratches. Fortunately, there are not many of them, according to reviews.
The reviews have complaints about the too heavy handle of the Neva pan. Because of this, it is not always convenient to keep it on weight, especially if food is being prepared inside for a large family. But the holder is strong and does not play. Buyers also like the placement of an additional small handle on the side. With it, it will be easy to hold the bowl with the second hand.
The undoubted leader in terms of the convenience of the handle was Rondell, the outsider was Mechta. In the latter, the holder turned out to be too heavy and uncomfortable, and the fastening is not very reliable. The handle of the Rondell is non-removable, but this did not stop her from getting high marks from buyers. The holder made of heat-resistant bakelite with silicone coating will provide comfortable use of kitchen utensils. But it is not recommended to put the pan in the oven, as well as washing it in the dishwasher.
Name | User rating for ease of care | User rating for a comfortable handle | User rating for quality |
Kukmara Granite Ultra | 4.9 | 4.8 | 4.9 |
Dream Granite | 4.7 | 4.6 | 4.7 |
Tefal Cook Right | 4.9 | 4.8 | 4.8 |
Rondell Massimo | 4.7 | 4.9 | 4.8 |
NEVA METAL WARE Special 90 | 4.7 | 4.7 | 4.6 |
4. Reliability and guarantees
Comparison of warranty periods and duration of operationCustomer reviews will also help us determine the reliability of kitchen utensils. For example, consumers consider the Kukmar frying pan to be the safest and most resistant to various kinds of damage. Its durability is amazing: dents do not appear with a slight collision or a fall from a small height. Some owners manage to stir and lay out food with a metal spoon, and even this does not spoil the surface of the product. Of course, careful handling will not hurt, otherwise there is a risk of significantly reducing the service life.
But Neva received record low scores for resistance to damage. The main complaint is rapid wear. The non-stick coating begins to peel off after a couple of years of active use. Unfortunately, the Tefal pan has a similar drawback, Teflon is enough for an even shorter period in comparison with the Russian competitor. To prolong the life of dishes, the reviews advise not to put them in the dishwasher, but to wash them with your hands and a sponge under running water.
Frying pans from the Dream and Rondell brands can be considered the golden mean. Yes, they are not the most durable and reliable, but they can withstand several years of active use. It is important to study the instructions and follow all the recommendations of the company, so as not to accidentally spoil the dishes.
If we talk about guarantees from the manufacturer, the Tefal brand stood out here, promising support for two years after purchase. Unfortunately, the declared service life of the pan is the shortest. Therefore, it is possible that in two years you really will have to throw away kitchen utensils and replace them with new ones. Other companies have a standard warranty period of 12 months. Rondell should serve up to 3 years, other models - about 5 years.
Name
| Life time | Manufacturer's Warranty | User rating for resistance to damage |
Kukmara Granite Ultra | 5 years | 1 year | 4.9 |
Dream Granite | 5 years | 1 year | 4.6 |
Tefal Cook Right | 2 years | 2 years | 4.5 |
Rondell Massimo | 3 years | 1 year | 4.7 |
NEVA METAL WARE Special 90 | 5 years | 1 year | 4.3 |
Kukmara Granite Ultra
Best quality
5. Popularity and reviews
Which model is most often discussed and searched by consumers?To determine the most popular non-stick frying pan, we studied hundreds of reviews on various resources, including Yandex.Market and other online stores. The disadvantages of each product deserve special attention, because the advantages are almost identical: the dishes are called safe, high-quality and easy to use.
Kukmara became the leader in the number of reviews and opinions on the network. It is important to understand that the abundance of reviews does not always indicate the best characteristics and quality of the product. Some buyers write their opinions only to warn others.But not in this case, because Kukmar's double-sided non-stick coating ensures the most uniform and fast cooking. Of course, the model also has disadvantages. The main one was the rapid appearance of scratches on the bottom, even if you use a silicone or wooden spatula.
As for the number of requests to Yandex.Wordstat, the most popular is Mechta. Oddly enough, there are fewer reviews about this model. Perhaps this is due to the better quality and lack of complaints, but buyers still note some disadvantages. These include strong absorption of odors and the rapid appearance of soot. On a black surface, this is almost invisible, but you should not choose light pans. The rest of the Dream is performing well. Even after a year of operation, the non-stick coating keeps well, the products almost do not stick. Heating is uniform, thanks to the thick walls and bottom, you can cook a variety of dishes.
The Neva model is criticized for its lengthy warm-up time - it usually takes about 5 minutes on a gas stove. But it has a really high-quality non-stick coating. You can fry pancakes in a dry frying pan, nothing will stick. And the meat is cooked with high quality, you just need to ignite the surface well.
The disadvantages of Rondell include a heavy handle. It outweighs, and therefore there is a risk of tipping the vessel over. Another nuance is the uneven heating on the induction cooker due to the small and thin soldering. But cooking on gas is convenient and pleasant. Food does not burn, the material heats up quickly.
Tefal is praised for its decent workmanship: it is easy to hold, food residues are quickly washed off, nothing remains on the surface.But the non-stick coating leaves much to be desired. Yes, it is absolutely safe and allows you to cook almost without oil, but over time, Teflon becomes thinner and wears off. Among the shortcomings, the high cost is most often mentioned, especially without discounts and promotions. Given that the pan comes without a lid, it seems overpriced.
Name | Reviews on different resources | Requests to Yandex.Wordstat per month |
Kukmara Granite Ultra | 566 | 2573 |
Dream Granite | 83 | 8306 |
Tefal Cook Right | 484 | 664 |
Rondell Massimo | 94 | 131 |
NEVA METAL WARE Special 90 | 558 | 440 |
NEVA METAL WARE Special 90
Maximum Reliability
6. Price
Choosing the most budget kitchen utensilsThe most budget in the ranking was Rondell. Even a version with a diameter of 28 cm will cost less than one and a half thousand rubles, and a small frying pan 24 cm can be bought a little more than 1000 rubles. Tefal is more expensive than other goods, but not by much. I am glad that during the sales period you can buy it at a significant discount. All other kitchen utensils are within the price range of 1500-1800 rubles. Quality corresponds to the cost of each model, so when choosing the best option, you should start from your capabilities and preferences.
Name | average price |
Kukmara Granite Ultra | 1689 rub. |
Dream Granite | 1590 rub. |
Tefal Cook Right | 1718 rub. |
Rondell Massimo | 1499 rub. |
NEVA METAL WARE Special 90 | 1650 rub. |
Rondell Massimo
Best price
7. Comparison results
Which frying pan has become the best in the ranking?Neva is a really reliable model, but it has its drawbacks. The main one was the impressive weight, which is associated with a thick bottom and walls. Yes, and long warming up is not happy. But the product has a durable and reliable coating, and there is also a removable handle. The Russian manufacturer is quite capable of competing with eminent foreign brands.
The next position in the ranking is Rondell - the only non-stick frying pan that can be placed on an induction stove. Alas, this did not help her to take a higher place. A serious advantage of the product is the most pleasant price, but according to other criteria, it failed to win or at least stand out from its competitors.
Tefal is in the middle of the ranking. At the same time, the thermospot became an advantage and a disadvantage of the pan, which for some reason does not work for all buyers. It benefits from high quality, ergonomic design and brand reputation. Those who consider Teflon coating the safest should take a closer look at this particular model.
The second place was taken by the Mechta non-stick frying pan. Although she won only one category, the model performed well in all criteria. Products are prepared evenly, the coating remains intact even after a year of use. An additional plus is the removable handle, thanks to which it will be possible to bake food in the oven. Apart from the difficulty of getting rid of the smell of food and the rapid appearance of soot, the product has no significant disadvantages.
The best in the ranking was Kukmara. She managed to win on several criteria at once, except that the cost of the goods is slightly higher than most pans.Of course, there are drawbacks, but they pale against the background of amazing resistance to damage and a long service life.
Name | Rating | Number of wins by criteria | Category winner |
Kukmara Granite Ultra | 4.92 | 3/6 | Ease of use, Reliability and guarantees, Popularity and reviews |
Dream Granite | 4.82 | 1/6 | Coating |
Tefal Cook Right | 4.78 | 1/6 | Dimensions and design |
Rondell Massimo | 4.75 | 1/6 | Price |
NEVA METAL WARE Special 90 | 4.73 | 0/6 | - |