№ |
Name |
Rating |
Nomination |
1 | Michelin Alpin 6 | 4.80 | The most durable Velcro tires |
2 | Bridgestone Blizzak Ice | 4.77 | The best tires for urban winter |
3 | Ice Zero Pirelli FR | 4.76 | Perfect cornering grip |
4 | Cordiant Winter Drive | 4.27 | The most affordable Velcro R16 |
1 | Continental Ice Contact 2 | 4.60 | Reliable braking on dry pavement and ice |
2 | Nokian Tires Hakkapeliitta 9 | 4.55 | A popular choice for harsh winters in size R16 |
3 | Goodyear UltraGrip Arctic 2 | 4.49 | Promising novelty of the year |
4 | Sailun Ice Blazer WST1 | 4.09 | Best price |
1 | Tigar Winter SUV | 4.84 | Popular Buyer's Choice |
2 | Yokohama Ice Guard SUV | 4.73 | Obedience in management |
3 | Michelin X-Ice North 4 SUV | 4.53 | The quietest tires among studs |
4 | Gislaved Nord Frost 200 SUV | 4.18 | The best combination of quality and price |
Winter tires in R16 size on the Russian market are one of the most popular positions. It is put on both cars and SUVs. In the latter case, a reinforced SUV modification is chosen. Especially for different winter conditions, manufacturers produce both studded tires and Velcro tires.Numerous tests by independent experts and owner reviews will tell you how not to make a mistake and make the best choice both in terms of performance and price.
Which tire brand to choose in 2021?
I would like to immediately draw attention to the novelty from good year. There are no reviews yet, but the manufacturer's statements and the results of the tests carried out are very encouraging - this proposal may be the most effective for the winter of 21-22. Traditionally reliable and manageable Velcro from Japan (Yokohama and Bridgestone) confidently retain the interest of car owners.
Models from Tigar and Gislaved. Even more affordable brands are not far behind them. Chinese Sailun and Russian Cordiant noticeably "pulled up" the quality of their rubber, and more and more confidently declare themselves on the market. Michelin, Nokian and Pirelli traditionally entered the top three most expensive tires. Their characteristics, if not perfect, are very close to ideal. Despite the high price tag, the products have a large number of admirers in Russia.
Criteria for choosing tires for winter
In addition to the size (in our case, it is R16), brand and price, the owner should pay attention to the following tire parameters:
Tread pattern. The symmetrical directional arrangement of the working part of the tire determines excellent hydroplaning resistance and good directional stability. Such a tire picks up speed quickly and is considered more economical. Asymmetry gives better stability when maneuvering, keeps a straight line well and drains water well from the contact patch.
Studding. The presence of lugs gives confidence on the winter road, where rolled snow alternates with ice and snow porridge.In conditions of clean or wet asphalt, such a tire is less practical, noisy, and the spikes wear out quickly.
Lamels. The more multidirectional cuts along the tread, the more confident the wheel "bites" into the surface. Velcro tires with an increased number of sipes perform well without lugs, maneuver confidently on wet roads and drive predictably through snow and ice. In the latter case, the braking distance is expectedly longer than that of studded tires.
Sidewall. Soft sidewalls for winter tires are commonplace. This feature gives stability on difficult surfaces, but during high-speed maneuvering it can lead to roll. If this part is stiff, handling and impact resistance will increase, but the tire will become rut sensitive.
The best Velcro winter tires
Top 4. Cordiant Winter Drive
Winter Velcro Cordiant Winter Drive has the most affordable price in the ranking. The difference with the category leader, the Serbian tire MICHELIN Alpin 6 is 50%.
- Average price: 4091 rubles.
- Country Russia
- Tread pattern: asymmetrical
- Speed index: T
The budget price tag is not the only advantage of the Cordiant Winter Drive winter Velcro. The experts of the Belarusian edition of Auto Bild during the tests were pleasantly surprised by the handling and braking on a snowy road. In this test, the rubber outperformed the European premium segment. But on the pavement, the driver needs an eye and an eye, since the braking distance turned out to be significantly longer than that of competitors. Real owners note low noise and confidence in driving, subject to the speed limit.At the same time, a non-studded tire at a near-zero temperature exhibits roll during rebuilding.
- Easy balancing
- Low cost
- Predictable behavior on snow
- Soft sidewall
- Valkost at zero
Top 3. Ice Zero Pirelli FR
Velcro Ice Zero Pirelli FR thanks to the rubber compound and tread architecture perfectly copes with lateral loads and maintains stable grip in the contact patch when maneuvering on any surface.
- Average price: 6920 rubles.
- Country: Romania
- Tread pattern: symmetrical
- Speed index: H, T
Premium Velcro tires on a winter road covered with snow and ice behave confidently, as if they were studded tires. On the rolled crust, maneuverability is maintained, as on clean asphalt. The braking distance in such conditions is comparable to the parameters of rubber with spikes, but on bare ice the tires do not show the best result of longitudinal grip. The predicted behavior of the Pirelli FR is confirmed by the experts of the edition "Behind the wheel". Tests in 2016 showed confident behavior on snow and asphalt, good handling on ice and economy when operating in urban areas.
- durable
- Sensitivity in control
- Holds the road well
- Doesn't like positive temperatures
Top 2. Bridgestone Blizzak Ice
High resistance to shock loads and wear, high traction and low noise level make Bridgestone Blizzak Ice Velcro the best choice for warm winters.
- Average price: 3938 rubles.
- Country: Japan
- Tread pattern: asymmetric
- Speed index: S
Thin ice, melting slush and water on the pavement - Bridgestone Blizzak Ice Velcro winter tires are the best "habitat". The asymmetry of the tread blocks and the successful selection of the rubber mixture provide confident grip during braking and high-speed maneuvering in such conditions. It is actively chosen by residents of cities and southern regions, where winter is traditionally mild. Non-studded rubber holds shock well, is wear-resistant and quite comfortable in terms of acoustics. These same characteristics have become the cause of the weak side of the tire - it immediately transfers all the bumps in the road to the steering wheel and to the interior of the car.
- Quiet
- Wear resistance
- Balanced price
- Sensitive to bumps in the road
- In the snow, the tread clogs quickly
Top 1. Michelin Alpin 6
MICHELIN Alpin 6, despite the softness of the rubber compound, has a unique resistance to abrasion, which allows you to use winter studless tires for 4-5 seasons or more.
- Average price: 8330 rubles.
- Country: France
- Tread pattern: symmetrical
- Speed index: H, T, V
Alpin 6 for mild winters is one of the best solutions. Velcro confidently behave in the snow and wet asphalt, very quiet. Tire tests in size 205/65 R16 (conducted by ADAC experts in 2019) showed hydroplaning resistance, high speed handling and effective braking. The wear resistance of rubber also causes sincere respect from the owners - tires serve for 4-5 seasons, maintaining excellent driving characteristics with a minimum tread thickness.The high price is attributed to the disadvantages, however, the 5-year manufacturer's warranty confirms that the tires are worth the money.
- High wear resistance
- Controllability
- Quiet
- Predictable braking
- High price
- Soft sidewall
See also:
The best winter tires with studs
Top 4. Sailun Ice Blazer WST1
Sailun Ice Blazer WST1 studded tires will cost half the price of the most popular Hakka 9 winter tires.
- Average price: 4190 rubles.
- Country: China
- Tread pattern: symmetrical
- Speed index: H, T
- Spikes: 130 pcs.
The domestic publication Avtocentre conducted a test of these Chinese tires back in 2016. Since then, the quality of Sailun Ice Blazer winter tires has changed for the better, but even then the tires showed excellent handling on wet roads. According to users, the Scandinavian tread pattern holds the road well in winter - powerful spikes and deep drainage systems confidently cope with ice porridge. But on dry asphalt, the shoe does not behave in the best way, sometimes there are complaints about the difficulty of balancing. However, the affordability of the R16 more than compensates for the weaknesses of the studded Ice Blazer WST1.
- Affordability
- Excellent wet handling
- Powerful lugs
- Poorly balanced
- Uncertain behavior on bare asphalt
Top 3. Goodyear UltraGrip Arctic 2
According to the manufacturer, the performance of the Goodyear UltraGrip Arctic 2 is superior to its predecessors.This is confirmed by the results of comparative tests by Test World.
- Average price: 10820 rubles.
- Country: USA
- Tread pattern: symmetrical
- Speed index: T
- Spikes: 220 pcs.
New studded tires from Goodyear have just appeared in Russian stores, and the guys from the Finnish Test World have already carried out comparative tests. UltraGrip Arctic 2 showed the best results in braking on ice and snow, as well as handling on wet pavement. The winter tire's combination of Snow Grip Velcro technology and Arctic Eagle Claw Stud gives the wearer confidence on any surface. The only drawback of tires is the temporary lack of reviews.
- Fresh rubber (2021 edition)
- Handling on any winter surface
- Increased number of grouser
- Snow grip technology
- Short stopping distance on ice
- Temporary no reviews
Top 2. Nokian Tires Hakkapeliitta 9
Excellent handling on icy roads, high snow flotation and resistance to wear and shock loads make the Hakkapeliitta 9 studded tire from Nokian Tires the most popular choice in regions with harsh winters.
- Average price: 8370 rubles.
- Country: Finland
- Tread pattern: symmetrical
- Speed index: T
- Spikes: 220 pcs.
The Finnish winter tire offers 8 tire sizes for R16 rims and has a separate line of heavy duty SUVs in this size. The tire is somewhat inferior to competitors in accelerating dynamics and braking, but maneuvering on snow and on slippery roads with studded tires is more than confident.Popular Science magazine was one of the first to test the 2017 novelty and awarded the Hakkapeliitta 9 as the best winter tire. The owners also positively evaluate the double studding (different types of lugs) and at the same time moderate noise, high wear resistance and shock resistance.
- Large selection of sizes for R16 wheels
- Wear and impact resistance
- Confident handling on snow and ice
- Excellent directional stability
- High price
- Braking distance on packed snow
See also:
Top 1. Continental Ice Contact 2
Winter tires IceContact 2 from the German Continental showed the best results of handling and braking on ice and bare asphalt in sub-zero temperatures. Independent tests were carried out by journalists from the tabloid Vi Bilagare and the auto magazine Teknikens Varld at the test sites in Sweden and Finland.
- Average price: 8130 rubles.
- Country: Germany
- Tread pattern: asymmetrical
- Speed index: T
- Spikes: 190 pcs.
In the tests of Teknikens Varld and Vi Bilagare (2017 and 2018 respectively), the IceContact 2 winter tires became number one peremptorily. Studded tires in the popular size 205/55/R16 showed the shortest stopping distance on ice and dry pavement, leaving behind Bridgestone and Nokian. The asymmetry of the directional pattern, the presence of lugs along the edges and in the center of the tread gave the expected results.As weak characteristics, the owners name the not very comfortable behavior of tires in a rut and the loss of up to half of the studs by the end of season 3.
- Perfectly balanced
- Short stopping distance
- High ice handling
- Secure cleat fit
- "Float" in a rut
See also:
The best winter tires for SUVs
Top 4. Gislaved Nord Frost 200 SUV
Gislaved Gislaved Nord Frost 200 SUV studded tires are based on Continental's advanced technology, which, combined with an affordable price, makes them the best offer on the market.
- Average price: 6560 rubles.
- Country: Portugal
- Tread pattern: asymmetrical
- Speed index: T
- Spikes: 130 pcs.
This is already the fifth season of the Nord Frost 200 SUV winter model from the budget subsidiary Continental. Gislaved uses the experience of a more famous brand, which makes the tire with a favorable price tag in no way inferior to the market leaders. Experts from Test World believe that this is one of the best studs for bare asphalt (tested in 2016). The tread perfectly removes snow porridge from the contact patch, and the asymmetric arrangement of the blocks also contributes to stability. The number of spikes does not create excessive acoustic pressure - the rubber is quite comfortable for urban use in winter. The owners of crossovers are satisfied with the choice, and among the shortcomings, only a soft sidewall is most often noted - it is better to protect the tire from impacts.
- Profitable price
- Good grip on ice
- Handling on bare pavement
- Soft sidewall
Top 3. Michelin X-Ice North 4 SUV
The special design of the stud seat ensures a low noise level when driving the Michelin X-Ice North 4 SUV on bare pavement.
- Average price: 13980 rubles.
- Country: France
- Tread pattern: symmetrical
- Speed index: H, T
- Spikes: 250 pcs.
The studded X-Ice North 4 SUV was developed in 2018 specifically for Russia and the Scandinavian countries, where harsh winters are in the order of things. Despite the rather impressive number of steel lugs (250 spikes are installed on the R16 tire), the tires demonstrate an unexpected noise level for them, comparable to the parameters of Velcro. The directional pattern and powerful siping of the tread showed decent handling results for heavy SUVs at the Test World test site. Owner reviews also serve as confirmation of the tests. For three winter seasons, except for the high price, no shortcomings could be found.
- R16 is for cars
- Excellent snow and ice handling
- Low abrasion
- Quiet
- High price
Top 2. Yokohama Ice Guard SUV
The rubber compound and tread features make the Ice Guard SUV one of the most compliant tires in high-speed maneuvering on winter roads.
- Average price: 9660 rubles.
- Country: Japan
- Tread pattern: asymmetric
- Speed index: Q
- Spikes: no
In 2018, tests by the Norwegian Autofil showed the high efficiency of the non-studded Ice Guard SUV and quite confident behavior on roads covered with snow and ice. Designed for harsh winters, Velcro has an asymmetrical tread with three support ribs. This gives excellent handling at speed and low rolling resistance.Drainage outlets from the contact patch are located at an angle, which makes the tire resistant to hydroplaning. A large number of multidirectional lamellas allows the rubber to literally "bite" into the coating. But there is also a drawback - fast abrasion.
- economical
- Low noise
- Handling at speed
- Rapid wear
Top 1. Tigar Winter SUV
The price advantage, handling, low noise level and high wear resistance have provided Tigar Winter SUV tires with a steadily growing demand in the domestic market.
- Average price: 5730 rubles.
- Country: Serbia
- Tread pattern: symmetrical
- Speed index: H, T, V
- Spikes: no
If anyone did not know, then the Tigar brand is a budget daughter of the French Michelin. For this reason, the winter Velcro of this brand is pretty good. They confidently cling to small ice, paddle well in the snow and during high-speed maneuvering. They overcome deep puddles without falling into aquaplaning, but the speed must be slowed down. The Belarusian edition ABW.BY three years ago tested non-studded Tigar Winter SUVs in the size 215/65 R16. It turned out that rubber in different conditions proved to be no worse than the premium segment.
- There is a light modification for passenger cars
- fair price
- Confident cornering grip
- Hydroplaning at speed
See also: