№ |
Name |
Rating |
Nomination |
1 | Michelin X-Ice North 4 | 4.94 | Best braking on ice |
2 | Nokian Tires Hakkapeliitta 9 | 4.90 | Balanced Features |
3 | Pirelli Ice Zero 2 | 4.87 | The best choice for northern regions |
4 | Kumho WinterCraft Ice WI31 | 4.85 | Best price |
5 | Yokohama Ice Guard IG65 | 4.82 | The strongest spikes |
1 | Bridgestone Blizzak DM-V3 | 4.92 | The most anticipated novelty of 2021 |
2 | Michelin X-ICE Snow | 4.88 | The most reliable tire of the Scandinavian type |
3 | Nokian Tires Hakkapeliitta R3 | 4.85 | Maximum fuel economy |
4 | Goodyear Ultra Grip Performance Plus | 4.84 | The most popular Velcro size R17 |
5 | Nexen Winguard Sport 2 | 4.80 | The optimum ratio of price and quality |
"Spikes or Velcro?" - the eternal question that every car owner asks before buying winter tires. With studded tires, everything is extremely simple - the tire design includes special spikes of various shapes and sizes that cling to a slippery road, providing stability when driving.
Non-studded tires are called friction tires.Good grip with the road surface is maintained thanks to the sipes, special channels and lugs. Friction tires are divided into two types, depending on the shape of the tread pattern - European, designed for regions with a temperate climate, and Scandinavian, designed for difficult operating conditions - severe frosts and snowy roads.
To protect yourself from mistakes, when choosing winter tires, you must consider the following factors:
Road type. For urban operating conditions, friction tires from the European type are considered the best solution. The same rubber can be advised to lovers of fast driving. But on snowy surfaces, Scandinavian-type tires can provide maximum comfort.
Road grip. Russian winters are always associated with snowdrifts and ice, but the widespread use of reagents has somewhat changed the situation. Thanks to the lamellas, Velcro is much better at maneuvering in wet slush.
Rubber composition. Due to the absence of spikes, softer and more elastic materials are used to make friction rubber. Some studded models also boast similar properties, but this falls into the category of the premium tire segment.
Environmental friendliness. If you plan to travel to Europe in winter by private car, you will have to refuse to buy studded tires due to the ban. It is believed that the use of such protectors leads to accelerated wear of the roadway and an increase in repair costs.Also, the governments of the countries take care of the environment - the dust generated by the friction of the spikes on the asphalt surface is very harmful and can cause cancerous tumors.
Noise level. The presence of spikes significantly reduces comfort when moving. This disadvantage manifests itself especially strongly when driving at high speed on dry asphalt.
It should be noted that manufacturers strive to eliminate the disadvantages for each type of rubber. It is thanks to this that modern studded tires move much quieter on dry asphalt, and Velcro owners feel confident enough even on slippery roads. When choosing tires, however, you should focus not only on the cost and reputation of the manufacturer, but also take into account the expected operating conditions and driving style.
The best studded tires
Top 5. Yokohama Ice Guard IG65
The special design and proper arrangement guarantees reliable fixation of the spikes, regardless of operating conditions.
- Average price: 10520 rubles
- Country: Japan
- Load index: 103 (up to 875 kg)
- Speed index: T (up to 190 km/h)
- Applicability: cars and crossovers
An all-round tire with an aggressive directional tread pattern designed for difficult operating conditions. The model performs especially well when driving on ice, which is not at all surprising, given the manufacturer's serious approach to the choice of studs. The studs are supplied by a company that is part of Continental AG. The barbs themselves have a strong figured body with a transversely oriented dumbbell-shaped insert that enhances the edge effect in all directions.The rubber compound with an increased proportion of microsilica reliably holds the studs in the tread, which is confirmed by numerous tests. The disadvantages include perhaps a fairly high noise level - a common problem for almost all studded models.
- Aggressive tread pattern
- Special spike shape
- Special stud body insert
- Durable rubber compound
- Noise level
Top 4. Kumho WinterCraft Ice WI31
With sufficiently good performance, the cost of this model is almost two times lower compared to its closest competitors.
- Average price: 6950 rubles
- Country: South Korea
- Load index: 93 (up to 650 kg)
- Speed index: T (up to 190 km/h)
- Applicability: cars and crossovers
Universal Korean rubber, which embodied an interesting technical solution. We are talking about an unusual arrangement of spikes. Here, the developers went against traditional practice and evenly distributed the spikes over the tread surface, focusing on the central part. This layout allows you to increase the controllability of the car on slippery surfaces. The rest of the model is an ordinary winter tire with a directional pattern without pretensions to originality. Although it is rather difficult to expect revolutionary technologies from rubber in this price segment.
- Low price
- Spike location
- Handling on ice
- Lack of proprietary solutions
See also:
Top 3. Pirelli Ice Zero 2
The second generation of the model was specially designed for difficult operating conditions.The test results confirm excellent performance and a high level of safety.
- Average price: 11383 rubles
- Country: Italy
- Load index: 98 (up to 750 kg)
- Speed index: H (up to 210 km/h)
- Applicability: cars, crossovers and SUVs
When developing the model, special attention was paid to the tread pattern, designed to cope with difficult winter obstacles. Widened edges of the V-grooves accelerate the removal of melted snow and water from the contact zone, which ensures stable control on wet surfaces. Transverse grooves are responsible for increasing traction and braking efficiency. The shape of the spike body was considered successful, and therefore remained the same. But the tungsten carbide carbide insert has received a new design. The advantages of the model include RUN FLAT ™ technology, which allows you to maintain control over the car during a tire puncture. Despite the excellent off-road performance, when driving on slush or wet asphalt, the performance is not impressive - for urban use, you can choose more interesting options.
- Special tread pattern
- Spike design
- Maintaining control over punctures
- Poorly suited for urban environments
Top 2. Nokian Tires Hakkapeliitta 9
The directional and symmetrical tread pattern, as well as two types of studs of different shapes, provide the same high level of grip on the surface when driving on ice, snow and wet asphalt.
- Average price: 10242 rubles
- Country: Finland
- Load index: 94 (up to 670 kg)
- Speed index: T (up to 190 km/h)
- Applicability: cars, crossovers and SUVs
The ninth generation of winter tires of the famous Hakkapeliitta series did not disappoint fans and received high marks in independent tests. When designing the model, the developers tried to take into account all the negative factors that the car faces in winter. Snow Grip Booster technology is responsible for confident movement on packed snow. Specially shaped slats increase vehicle stability when maneuvering. Brass-coated twisted steel wire cord is characterized by increased adhesion to the rubber part, which has a positive effect on control. Despite the efforts of the developers, the only weak point of the model is the high noise level, especially during the break-in.
- Balanced Features
- High strength cord
- Positive scores from independent tests
- Large selection of R17 sizes
- Loud noise
Top 1. Michelin X-Ice North 4
For this model, the manufacturers have developed a special tread pattern, which made it possible to place 250 studs on the surface of the R17 tire, providing excellent grip on ice.
- Average price: 15179 rubles
- Country: France
- Load index: 103 (up to 875 kg)
- Speed index: T (up to 190 km/h)
- Applicability: cars, crossovers and SUVs
The Michelin Group introduced this model back in 2018, setting a record number of studs made of a special iron-based alloy that is resistant to external aggressive influences. This decision made it possible to even out the degree of wear of the tread and studs.Thanks to a special placement algorithm, a large number of studs significantly improve braking performance with a minimum level of noise exposure. It is also worth noting the competent approach of the manufacturer to the choice of rubber compound. The outer layer of the tread in contact with the road surface is made of new generation elastomers, which are characterized by a low glass transition temperature. This feature allows the rubber to remain elastic even in the most severe winters, however, at positive temperatures, the tires become too soft - in the spring it is better not to tighten with changing shoes.
- Ice braking
- Uniform tread and stud wear
- Acoustic comfort
- Resistant to critically low temperatures
- Excessive softness at positive temperature
- High price
See also:
The best non-studded tires
Top 5. Nexen Winguard Sport 2
Affordable winter Velcro that performs reasonably well on a variety of surfaces including ice, sleet and clean asphalt.
- Average price: 9030 rubles
- Country: South Korea
- Load index: 97 (up to 730 kg)
- Speed index: V (up to 240 km/h)
- Applicability: cars
Universal Korean tire, which is distinguished by a well-thought-out symmetrical tread pattern adapted to difficult operating conditions. Three-dimensional sipes increase the stability of the rubber on snow and provide rigidity on dry surfaces. Double curved grooves improve traction on slippery surfaces. For effective water drainage, there are grooves made in the form of a zigzag.Judging by the reviews, the rubber has no obvious flaws. Some owners experienced balancing difficulties before the second season, but this can be attributed to storage violations.
- Affordable cost
- Handling on wet surfaces
- Stability on snowy roads
- Possible balancing issues
Top 4. Goodyear Ultra Grip Performance Plus
Sufficiently affordable cost and excellent performance make this model extremely interesting for a wide range of drivers.
- Average price: 10980 rubles
- Country: USA
- Load index: 91 (up to 615 kg)
- Speed index: H (up to 210 km/h)
- Applicability: cars
Winter friction tires of the European type, designed for high-speed passenger cars. The model received a tread pattern from its predecessor, but the manufacturers worked on the composition of the rubber compound, which made it possible to improve the behavior of the tire on winter roads. In the production of a new rubber compound, Traction Protect technology was used - a special resin was added to the base composition, which helps to quickly restore shape after deformation, converting braking force into grip on the surface. But the Winter Grip technology allows the rubber to maintain elasticity at low temperatures. However, some drivers complain about the excessive elasticity of the rubber, which has a bad effect on the car's handling, especially at high speeds.
- Suitable for high speed driving
- High quality tread pattern
- New rubber compound
- High grip on surfaces
- Mixed reviews about elasticity
Top 3. Nokian Tires Hakkapeliitta R3
Excellent rolling resistance has a positive effect on fuel consumption, which is confirmed by the results of research.
- Average price: 11800 rubles
- Country: Finland
- Load index: 93 (up to 650 kg)
- Speed index: R (up to 170 km/h)
- Applicability: cars, crossovers and SUVs
The tread of the model is made in accordance with the Arctic Sense Grip concept - sipes and grooves are combined into a single network with a special structure that provides reliable grip on any surface. The raw material used for the exterior is Nokian's own developed Cryo Crystal 3 heat-resistant compound, which contains fine particles with sharp edges. They begin to show positive qualities as the tread wears, increasing stability on slippery surfaces. The weak point of the model can be considered a low speed index: traditionally, higher performance is expected from friction tires.
- Good grip on all surfaces
- Rubber compound with sharp particles
- rolling resistance
- Economical fuel consumption
- Low speed index
Top 2. Michelin X-ICE Snow
According to the manufacturer's internal tests and independent examinations, the performance of the control stability and braking efficiency of the model is much higher compared to direct competitors.
- Average price: 13110 rubles
- Country: France
- Load index: 93 (up to 650 kg)
- Speed index: H (up to 210 km/h)
- Applicability: cars, crossovers and SUVs
Testing of this Velcro was carried out in difficult climatic conditions of Northern Europe.This circumstance allows us to hope that the developers carefully prepared for any tests. Compared to the previous generation, manufacturers have increased the width of the drainage channels, and also used several types of sipes that increase traction on snow and maintain rigidity when maneuvering. It is also worth noting that, unlike most analogues, the model is practically not subject to a decrease in performance as the tread wears out. Motorists find it difficult to find flaws in this model. Some drivers note difficulties with driving on ice. On the other hand, stability on slippery surfaces has never been a strong suit of friction tires.
- Wide drainage channels
- Good snow traction
- Maneuverability
- Consistent performance throughout the lifetime
- Difficulty driving on slippery surfaces
See also:
Top 1. Bridgestone Blizzak DM-V3
The high degree of controllability, safety and durability, confirmed by the test results, made the models the most popular novelty of this year.
- Average price: 13349 rubles
- Country: Japan
- Load index: 100 (up to 800 kg)
- Speed index: S (up to 180 km/h)
- Applicability: crossovers and SUVs
The flagship model from a well-known Japanese manufacturer, designed for crossovers and SUVs. Thanks to the use of the latest technical developments, the model is ideal for operation in the harshest conditions. For the manufacture of the rubber compound, Active Multicell Compound technology is used, which guarantees the elasticity of the tire in the most severe frosts.The new tread design has improved directional stability on wet surfaces and slush. The double frame of the side part provides resistance to the high loads that occur when driving off-road. The only thing you want to demand from the model is an affordable price: the price of the novelty is quite high.
- Suitable for difficult conditions
- Elasticity at critically low temperatures
- Driving stability on wet surfaces and slush
- Double side frame
- High price